Collection · 6 entries
Words That Changed Meaning
Six terms whose current sense is not their first one, each with both senses dated. A dictionary records where a word ended up. What this set records is the distance travelled, which is usually the more interesting fact and is almost never printed.
Transgender is the largest shift: John Oliven used it in 1965 for something considerably narrower than the umbrella it names now, and the widening happened in the 1990s, which is why sources from either side of that decade appear to contradict each other. Genderflux moved the other way, from a broad 1994 sense of shifting between genders to the precise modern one about intensity rather than direction. Butch began as general slang for masculine, tied to an abbreviation of butcher and to an outlaw's nickname, before becoming a central identity in lesbian bar culture in the 1940s. Mahu is the hardest case in the set, since the change was done to the word rather than by it: a ceremonial Hawaiian role turned into a slur under missionary and American rule and has been deliberately reclaimed since the 1990s. The set is ordered by how far each word travelled. It excludes terms that merely broadened in scope without changing what they claim, and it excludes the ones whose first sense is undocumented, which is most of the microlabels.
Plate for the collection
Hand-set, never alphabetical
The set, in order
6 entries
- TransgenderFrom a narrow 1965 medical sense to the 1990s umbrella. The reason sources on either side of that decade seem to disagree.
- MahuA ceremonial role made into a slur by missionary and American rule, then reclaimed from the 1990s. Change done to the word.
- GenderfluxNarrowed rather than widened: from shifting between genders in 1994 to fluctuating intensity now.
- ButchGeneral slang for masculine, from an abbreviation of butcher, before the lesbian sense settled in the 1940s.
- Akava'ineAn old dictionary word carrying a modern identity that was assembled in the New Zealand diaspora and carried home.
- GenderqueerUnchanged in definition and changed in position, from the standard term to the marked alternative to non-binary.
Keep going
The other collections
- The Pairs People Mix UpFour pairs of gender terms that get mixed up constantly, and what each pair actually turns on: the body, the axis, the register, or a plain category error.
- Categories That Resist TranslationSeven gender categories routinely given as the local word for transgender, and the specific reason each of those renderings fails.
- The Vocabulary of the 1990sSeven words first attested between 1992 and 1996, made in zines and newsletters before the general internet, carrying most of the framework still in use.
- The Numbers That Get MisquotedSix figures quoted constantly without the sentence that makes them mean anything, including one that fell sixfold because a checkbox was removed.